Tide Turning Against Authors of Restrictive Immigration Measures

Over the last few weeks, the media has slowly picked up on the tepid response state legislatures have given to copycat immigration enforcement measures, noting the gradual cooling of enthusiasm and support for these highly divisive measures. Lawmakers, under pressure from business groups, have already shot down enforcement measures in Arizona, Colorado, Iowa, Kentucky, Nebraska, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Virginia, and Wyoming while other states, like Kansas, draw closer to permanently stalling these bills. While these battles are far from over, the response of key supporters indicates that they, too, know that the public is becoming disenchanted. Today, Politico ran an editorial by Arizona state Senator and author of SB 1070, Russell Pearce, who, in what sounded like a cross between a crusader and a sore loser, attempted to defend his honor against the recently failed package of immigration measures in Arizona.

In his editorial, state Sen. Pearce goes backwards through time to prove that while his current package of get-tough immigration bills may have failed, he has, in fact, previously succeeded in passing restrictive immigration measure.

Prior to SB 1070, I introduced many other measures that addressed illegal immigration — and eventually became law. In 2004, 56 percent of Arizona voters approved Prop 200, which denies certain government benefits to illegal immigrants and prevents voter fraud.

While this may be true, Sens. Pearce’s defense sounds a lot like a politician backed into a corner. To make matters worse, Pearce also went after the business community, labeling them the “cheap labor lobby.”

Much has been made of an open letter that 60 chief executive officers of Arizona businesses sent me, urging the Legislature not to “pass any additional immigration legislation.” They focused on the supposed negative effects of a boycott of Arizona. But it is not unreasonable to suspect that a desire for cheap labor was also a factor.

Really? “The supposed negative effects?” Sen. Pearce might want to ask the state’s convention industry about the estimated $141 million it lost in cancelled conferences this year or check with the tourism industry, which lost 3,000 jobs and $490 million in revenue due to SB 1070.

Meanwhile, Hispanic legislators in Kansas, where an Arizona-style bill was recently tabled, are blowing the whistle on the bill’s author, Kris Kobach. As we’ve reported before, Kobach, a well-known restrictionist and Kansas’s Secretary of State, has hired himself out to city councils across the country to write, and subsequently defend from lawsuits, ordinances that target unauthorized immigrants. Four Hispanic legislators—three Republicans and one Democrat—specifically named Kobach as one of the reasons Kansas has engaged in a divisive immigration debate. The legislators sponsored a resolution similar to the Utah Compact which calls immigration a federal issue that “needs to be dealt with on that level.”

And while the rebuke of effort by Sen. Pearce, Secretary of State Kobach, and others is welcome news for fans of common sense, it is far too early to pat anyone on the back. Pearce and the groups that have long supported him, like the Immigration Reform Law Institute (IRLI), made progress because they have been continually chipping away at a sense of balance in the immigration debate. Proponents of good immigration policies, fiscal responsibility, and state civility have to be equally prepared to push back time and again. Clearly, though, these efforts are getting under Pearce’s skin—one drop of water at a time.

Photo by intheozone.

email

Subscribe

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe now to receive more just like it.

Subscribe via RSS Feed
  • http://cox.net Icy

    Sen. Pearce is well on his way to being recalled with 6,000 signatures gathered to date. His taking money from the Fiesta Bowl now fired CEO doesn’t help his cause. He is on the way out, then the recall group can focus on other legislatures who have been happy to follow his footsteps. Republicans are part of the movement to recall Pearce. While cut backs are occuring across the state for schools, etc. these politicos continue to harp on immigration. As we watch immigrants leave their homes here our businesses continue to close their doors. The housing industry continues to spiral into hell. There is something wrong with senators that hang out with know white supremacists such as J.T. Ready….they lose their crediability sense we all know this isn’t about immigration reform. It is about ethnic cleansing. Pearce should clean out his own closet including the possible abusive behavior of his son. His son has had more than one problem with the law….now Pearce has some explaining to do about the thousands he accepted from the Fiesta Bowl.

Top